S. Trial Skills: Immigration

Course Information

Course Number
L8412
Curriculum Level
Upperclass
Areas of Study
Legal Profession and Professional Responsibility
Type
Seminar
Additional Attributes
Experiential Credit

Section 001 Information

Instructor

Section Description

Method of Evaluation: There is no final examination or paper. There are three short writing assignments. Students must come to class prepared to actively participate in, and to promote, lively discussions and exercises so that all of the class can learn and can excel. Two case briefings and one observation in any Immigration Court with an essay of the student’s impressions of trial techniques observed are mandatory and due as noted in the syllabus. Attendance is mandatory. If there is an emergency, contact the professor immediately.

This is a 3 credit (42 hour) course. It is a hybrid of a trial skills class, relevant to theories of relief from removal from this country. It will include discussion and analysis of current law governing the removal from United States of foreign-born individuals by utilizing a dozen precedential reported cases which set forth the prima facie elements of relief from removal. We will review eligibility requirements of these protections against removal using these same cases. Students will, throughout the course, also utilize a National Institute of Trial Advocacy (NITA) type based method of developing testimonial evidence from historical case law that illustrates the prima facie elements for the forms of relief.

This is not a policy or research course. The skills students will learn in this class are persuasion and advocacy skills which can be used in any courtroom, arbitration, negotiation or public speaking setting. Students will learn how to do basic opening statements, conduct direct and cross examinations of a fact witness and an expert witness, and will learn how to do a closing statement. This is a participatory class. In the various exercises, students may be assigned to be a witness or a lawyer for either the respondent or the Department of Homeland Security.

School Year & Semester
Fall 2021
Location
WJWH 103
Schedule
Class meets on
  • Monday
6:20 pm - 9:10 pm
Points
3
Method of Evaluation
Other
J.D Writing Credit?
No

Learning Outcomes

Primary
  • (a) Knowledge and understanding of how to communicate effectively by enhancing storytelling skills: 1. Messages must humanize, dramatize, and organize. 2. Verbal content must be clear. 3. Paralinguistics should reinforce content.
  • (b) Learn how to develop a case theory (your side’s version of what happened): 1. Use themes and labels. 2. Select a theory-your client’s version of what happened-incorporate facts and legal elements. 3. Establish your client as the “good guy.”
  • (c) Craft a compelling opening statement: 1. Establish a trial vocabulary. 2. Select themes and labels that summarize your case. 3. Outline the story and use certain buzzword (words that express the key legal concepts and facts). 4. Do three things in the first three minutes—grab attention, state themes, give short overview.
  • (d) Conduct a direct examination: 1. Let the witness be the star - 5 WH questions. 2. Do not tell the trier of fact what happened. Recreate what happened through the witness’ eyes. 3. Learn to structure a clear, simple, logical direct examination. 4. Learn to incorporate “bad” facts.
  • (e) Conduct a cross examination: 1. Learn how to control a witness. 2. Formulate leading questions to keep the witness to short answers. 3. Utilize techniques to elicit favorable information for your side and expose weaknesses in the witness’ testimony.
  • (f) Develop a closing statement based upon facts divulged during the examinations: 1. Learn how to use the facts that come out at trial to make an effective closing statement. 2. Make concise impactful points. 3. Utilize the theory, theme, and labels.

Course Limitations

Instructor Pre-requisites
None
Instructor Co-Requisites
None
Recommended Courses
None
Other Limitations
None