L9080 SEMINAR: BLACK LETTER LAW AND WHITE-COLLAR CRIME (3 pts)
(see Criminal Law)
L8231 SEMINAR: CAPITAL MARKETS: DEVELOPMENT, STRUCTURE AND POLICIES (2 pts)
Meyer Eisenberg
This course focuses on issues raised by such questions as: What is "The Market" and how does it really work? How is the market for securities trading structured in the United States? How did it get to where it is today? What is the effect of "globalization" on our markets and on non-U.S. markets? Where do we go from here in terms of structure and regulatory policy—and how should we get there?
As the title indicates, we will examine the development, structure, operation and regulation of the various components of the U.S. capital market and the legal and policy questions raised by the various constituencies participating in the market (e.g., broker-dealers; investment banks; institutional investors—including mutual funds, hedge funds, pension funds, banks and insurance companies; and private investors and issuers) and the regulatory regimes that have been imposed on them. We shall review the evolution, growth and current structure of the securities markets themselves: the NYSE, NASDAQ, the ECN's, the options and futures markets. For example, how did we get from the NYSE's "closed club" of privileged members with exclusive access to the trading floor, with fixed commission rates and specialists, floor traders and odd-lot brokers executing buy and sell orders on the exchange's floor, using an "open outcry" form of trading model, to the freer, electronic, more competitive, and more open markets we see today? We will review the SEC's progress in fashioning intermarket standards through the "NMS" and other rulemaking efforts on "soft dollars," directed brokerage and other market practices. What are the appropriate goals and policies for the future in light of the rapid advances in technology and international 24-hour trading?
The recent merger of the NYSE with an ECN (Archipelago) and the possible merger of the NY or the NASDAQ with the London Stock Exchange, or the emergence of an EU Frankfurt-London-Amsterdam consortium, exemplify the velocity of change in the markets as well as the benefits and possible consequences of the "globalization" of securities markets and financial service entities that is currently taking place. The consolidation of financial services firms both in the U.S. (e.g., Blackrock/Merrill Lynch, J.P. Morgan/Chase) and in foreign markets (e.g., Deutsche Bank and its U.S. affiliates) as well as the acquisition of U.S. public companies by non-U.S. companies (e.g., Daimler/Chrysler) all raise both regulatory, operational and economic issues worthy of consideration. Further, such matters as the recent Securities Act reporting, disclosure and offering reforms, the limits of "stabilization," the due diligence duties of underwriters (e.g., WorldCom) and the role of the antitrust laws, in the context of relevant securities regulations, affect markets in the U.S. and abroad. All of these matters deserve examination, and an understanding of these issues in the context of a global market is important to persons interested in the functioning of capital markets, coordination of securities regulatory standards, including disclosure, accounting and enforcement issues and efforts to resolve existing differences in process and substantive issues.
Selected financial service executives and government officials will discuss the role, operation and regulatory policies that affect their organizations and their view of the future for the financial services industry.
L9805 SEMINAR: COMPARATIVE & INTERNATIONAL ANTITRUST (2 pts)
(see Administrative Law and Public Policy)
L9519 SEMINAR: CONTEMPORARY CORPORATE LAW SCHOLARSHIP: READING GROUP (2 pts)
J. Gordon
We will read and discuss current articles and working papers on a series of topics: corporate governance, comparative corporate governance, and takeovers. Students will write 8 short reaction papers over the course of the semester and one longer paper that extends one of the reaction papers. With the instructor's permission, students may undertake substantial research papers for extra credit.
Since the papers selected are at the cutting edge of the discipline and will often be presented by the author, the seminar may be particularly interesting to students contemplating academic careers.
L9519 SEMINAR: THE CORPORATION AND MODERN SOCIETY (2 pts)
H. Goldschmid, P. Lochner
This seminar focuses, on an advanced level, on principal legal and economic questions facing major corporations today. Among the subjects considered are: (1) a re-evaluation of the consequences of the divorce of corporate control from ownership; (2) the status and practicability of "shareholder democracy"; (3) proper corporate goals; (4) the corporation and its constituencies (shareholders, labor, consumers, etc.); (5) the governance of the corporation and the duties and responsibilities of corporate directors, officers, and insiders; (6) the role of the corporate lawyer; (7) the role - and recent activism - of institutional investors; and (8) the respective roles of state corporation law and federal securities law. In addition, we will consider selected, important issues involving federal securities regulation. It is expected that the seminar will be joined by a number of guests with expertise in particular areas.
L9007 SEMINAR: CURRENT ISSUES IN CORPORATE GOVERNANCE (2 pts)
J. Fried, J. Gordon
"Corporate governance" has long been an important topic. Now it seems an urgent one. The seminar tries to assess the reasons for that urgency as it focuses on key current developments. Among the topics to be considered: the changing ownership structure of the US public firm; executive compensation; the arguments pro and con for "shareholder empowerment"; the rise of hedge funds; the changing functions of corporate boards; and the competition between US and other jurisdictions as the exemplar for corporate governance practice. The readings will be drawn from regulatory materials, cases, law review articles and empirical literature in other disciplines. Students will be asked to write a series of short papers in the course of the seminar and a medium paper expanding on a short paper at the end.
L8183 Seminar: Deals Litigation (2 pts)
(see Commercial Law and Advanced Contract Law)
L9253 Seminar: Deals Workshop: The Art of the Deal (2 pts)
M. Greenberg-Kobrin, A. Kaufman, J. McHugh, S. Semer
The Workshop explores the lawyer's role in structuring and implementing business transactions to create value, manage business risk, and promote client interests in a complex legal and regulatory environment. Building on principles explored in the Deals course, workshop participants are asked to engage in negotiation and drafting exercises that put the theory to the test. We draw on modern negotiation theory to explore the tension between value creation and value division and to examine different methods of negotiation and persuasion. The objective is to improve our ability to identify and effectively address recurring problems in deal structuring and negotiations. Significant attention is paid to all aspects of the writing process, including drafting term sheets,working with forms, writing e-mails and formal and informal memoranda for clients, and drafting contract language, as well as structuring and negotiating business transactions. Students will be required to turn in short written assignments in advance of class. Experienced corporate lawyers will participate in some of the classes to add additional perspectives to the course.
Further description available at www.law.columbia.edu/deals.
L9253 SEMINAR: DEALS WORKSHOP: MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS (2 pts)
I. Kirman, T. Norwitz
The class moves at a fast pace and class participation accounts for approximately one-third of the grade, so fluent English is highly recommended. If you don't come to the first class and do the first assignment you may be dropped from the class or waitlist.
The Workshop aims to fill the gap between academic theory and law firm transactional practice by introducing students to basic deal-making techniques - analyzing, drafting and negotiating transactional documents. The Workshop will focus on transactions in the field of mergers and acquisitions, which will include a variety of public company and private deals, and will be taught by two partners from the firm of Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz.
A portion of the classes will be devoted to understanding the theoretical underpinnings of contracting and deal-making generally, but the primary focus of the Workshop will be to give practical exposure to students who are interested in mergers and acquisitions transactional work. Where possible, we will use real deal documents from prior transactions. Students will have an opportunity to participate in strategy sessions, drafting exercises and negotiations, and will also be required to turn in short written assignments from time to time.
L9253 SEMINAR: DEALS WORKSHOP: TRANSACTIONAL LEGAL STRATEGIES (2 pts)
I. Nissan
The Workshop explores the lawyer's role in structuring and implementing business deals to create value, manage business risks, and promote client interests in a complex legal and regulatory environment. The course utilizes many case studies from hypothetical and actual private equity deals. Participants are asked to engage in negotiation and drafting exercises. We draw on modern negotiation theory to explore the tension between value creation and value division and to examine different methods of negotiation and persuasion. The objective is to improve our ability to identify and effectively address recurring problems in deal structuring and negotiations. Significant attention is paid to all aspects of the writing process, including drafting term sheets, writing e-mails and formal and informal memoranda for clients, and drafting contract language. Students will be required to turn in short written assignments from time to time.
L9064 SEMINAR: DERIVATIVES LAW AND REGULATION (2 pts)
R. Miller, S. Selig
Derivatives (e.g., futures, forwards, options and swaps) are essential to the means and mechanisms of modern global finance. They are employed by financial institutions, major corporations, institutional investors and high net-worth individuals both to manage risk relating to their business and investments and to seek to generate profits. This seminar will introduce students to the different types of derivatives markets and U.S. regulation of these markets. Specifically it will explore the different market structures for derivatives that are permissible under U.S. law: formal, organized exchanges; derivatives transaction facilities; electronic trading facilities and over-the-counter markets; the types of instruments that may be traded on each; the types of traders who can use each; and the different levels of regulatory supervision applicable to each. The course will also consider the legal elements and negotiable variables of OTC derivatives, including the common ISDA master agreement and schedule. We will also consider the role played by intermediaries and liquidity providers (such as brokers and hedge funds). Lastly, we will consider the policy and systemic implications of derivatives and their users.
L8343 SEMINAR: INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AND INVESTMENT TRANSACTIONS WITH CHINA (2 pts)
(see International, Foreign and Comparative Law)
L9126 SEMINAR: LAW AND ECONOMICS OF CORPORATE AND SECURITIES MARKETS (3 pts)
Goshen
This seminar discusses economic and legal policy aspects of various issues in corporate and securities law. Topics include the interplay between the different agency problems in the corporate setting (shareholders-managers; majority-minority; shareholders-bondholders), conflict of interests and strategic voting among shareholders, bondholders rights, takeovers, insider dealing, and fraud and manipulation in securities market. The seminar is designed for students with interest in financial or economic approaches to corporate and securities law. However, no formal knowledge of these areas is required.
L9577 SEMINAR: LAW, GOVERNANCE AND CAPITALISM (3 pts)
R. Gilson, C. Milhaupt
This seminar will explore, through in-depth analysis of the latest theoretical and empirical scholarship, a series of important issues in the relationship between legal rules and the governance problems of market-oriented economies. After a theoretical introduction to the link between legal systems and economic growth, the seminar will examine the distinct corporate governance problems faced in the major ownership structures around the world: the dispersed shareholder model (U.S. and U.K.), the controlling shareholder model (much of Asia, Europe and Latin America) and the state ownership model (found most prominently in China).
The seminar will be the first in-depth offering at the Law School on the corporate governance problems of state owned enterprises (SOEs). Despite the declining influence of the state in economic activity around the world, SOEs and their affiliates are central actors in important transition economies such as China, India and Brazil. Yet the special governance problems of SOEs have been largely neglected in the corporate governance literature. Our seminar will be a vehicle for exploring the issues raised by the rise of state-affiliated economic actors in today???s global economy.
L9132 SEMINAR: NON-PROFIT INSTITUTIONS (2 pts)
H. Goldschmid, P. Swords
This seminar broadly examines the function and rationale for nonprofit institutions in American society. What do they do and why is it done by them rather than private commercial enterprises or government entities? In this connection, a brief examination is made of the size and significance of this "third sector" and of the characteristics of the various types of nonprofit organizations (i.e. social groups, hospitals, arts organizations, educational institutions and foundations). Considerable attention is given to the taxation of nonprofit organizations, including a consideration of the rationale for charitable exemptions, the unrelated business income tax and the impact of the 1969, 1986 and 1993 Tax Reform Acts. In addition, consideration is given to the use of the corporate form by nonprofit organizations: the advantages that accrue from such use, and alternative methods of organizing in a nonprofit manner. Comparisons are made with commercial enterprises.
The seminar deals with the lawyer's role in forming, chartering, obtaining a tax exemption for, and providing counseling to nonprofit organizations. Some time is spent discussing proper goals of nonprofit institutions and the role and responsibilities of their directors and officers. An examination is made of the ways nonprofit organizations are misused and of the various methods used by the government to regulate them. Policy issues that concern nonprofit institutions in general are covered, including restrictions on their spheres of activity, tax and antitrust policies, new forms of private and public finance, and the rights of various parties to bring suit.
L8180 SEMINAR: PRIVATE INVESTMENT FUNDS (2 pts)
M. Nissan
This seminar will study private investment funds, with a particular focus on venture capital and buyout funds. It will also cover other forms of private equity funds, as well as hedge funds. Students will examine the economic and legal relationships between a fund's sponsor (i.e., the general partner) and a fund's investors (i.e., the limited partners), as well as the economic and legal relationships among a fund's managers, inter se. Areas of focus will include whether present-day funds, from an economic and legal perspective, are, in fact, structured in a manner that results in "alignment of interests" rather than "conflicts of interest" between fund sponsors and managers, on the one hand, and fund investors, on the other hand.
Other issues to be examined in the course include (I) the regulatory framework within which private investment funds operate, including certain aspects of the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Investment Company Act of 1940, the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 and ERISA that relate to the offering and management of private investment funds, and (II) a discussion of certain tax considerations involved in structuring private funds, such as capital gain "carried interest" incentive arrangements.
A multidisciplinary approach will be used combining economic, tax, legal, and financial analysis of the subject matter. Guest speakers will include representatives of a leading private equity firm. Students will participate in a case study of such firm and a negotiation exercise involving the terms of a fund to be sponsored by such firm. Ideally student enrolled in this seminar will have some background in finance, accounting, economics, taxation, and securities law. Although by no means essential, students may find some prior exposure to partnership taxation helpful.
L9733 SEMINAR: SELECT ISSUES IN NONPROFIT GOVERNANCE (2 pts)
M. Leslie
This two-credit course will focus on the governance mechanisms affecting nonprofit corporations. After an initial xploration of the theory and structure of the nonprofit corporation, we will study how state fiduciary duty law and the federal tax code police the conduct of nonprofit executives. With a critical eye, we will compare the accountability mechanisms of nonprofit law to those governing publicly-traded corporations, trusts, and foundations, and determine whether current trends in nonprofit governance law are well founded or misguided. We will study other governance issues as well, including limits on the conduct of educational and religious institutions, limits on lobbying and campaign activities, and the unrelated business income tax.